The Quiet Decline in Enforcement
Just after Christmas, FINRA quietly updated its database with news of a multi-million-dollar penalty against a major brokerage for allegedly losing track of almost a million trades. This substantial fine, along with earlier sanctions against other prominent financial institutions, went largely unnoticed due to a lack of press releases.
This quiet approach to major enforcement actions is part of a larger trend. Enforcement actions have fallen to the lowest level in FINRA’s history, while total fines have decreased by about half since peaking in 2016. The regulator now issues press releases for only a fraction of its enforcement actions compared to previous years.
This decline in enforcement and publicity has raised eyebrows among industry experts and former FINRA officials. There’s growing concern about the regulator’s ability to catch the next big fraud, with some wondering if FINRA will be prepared when the next financial crisis hits.
FINRA’s Defense and Industry Perspectives
FINRA maintains that it hasn’t strayed from its mission. They argue that the decrease in enforcement actions is due to their success in reducing the number of bad actors in the industry over time. The regulator claims to prioritize cases involving repeat offenders and customer harm, and to address multiple matters in single enforcement actions when appropriate.
While FINRA’s enforcement numbers have declined, the SEC’s have remained relatively steady. This discrepancy has caught the attention of lawmakers, with some planning to investigate the drop-off in enforcement.
Some brokers, however, argue that FINRA’s previous approach was too heavy-handed. Industry professionals suggest that examiners often focused too much on minor violations and well-intentioned small companies rather than firms actively trying to skirt the rules.
Looking Ahead: Challenges and Concerns
As the financial landscape continues to evolve with new platforms and technologies, the need for vigilant oversight remains crucial. The question remains: Will FINRA’s current approach be sufficient to detect and prevent the next major financial fraud?
While FINRA maintains that its reduced enforcement actions reflect improved industry behavior, critics worry that the watchdog may be losing its bite at a time when financial innovation could be opening new avenues for abuse. As we move forward, it will be essential to monitor how FINRA balances its regulatory responsibilities with the evolving needs of the industry and investors alike.
To learn more, click here.
